...

qazisolicitors

Road Accident Liability Disputes: Evidence and Shared Fault

September 8, 2025 admin Comments Off

Road accident liability disputes: evidence and shared fault

Updated 13 November 2026. General guidance for injury claims in England and Wales.

If the other driver or their insurer denies responsibility, identify what is disputed and which evidence could resolve it. A denial does not itself decide the claim. Equally, being injured in a collision does not automatically establish that someone else must pay compensation.

For immediate steps at the scene, use our road traffic accident safety and evidence checklist. This guide focuses on disagreements about responsibility after the incident.

What does disputed liability mean?

The parties may disagree about how the collision happened, whether a driver failed to take reasonable care, or whether that failure caused the injury and loss claimed. An insurer may also accept some responsibility while arguing that the injured person contributed to the damage. Ask for the position and reasons in writing rather than relying on a telephone summary.

Can you claim if you were partly at fault?

Partial fault does not automatically defeat a claim. Under section 1 of the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945, where damage results partly from the claimant’s fault and partly from another person’s fault, compensation is reduced to reflect the claimant’s responsibility as the court considers fair. The circumstances and evidence determine whether a reduction is appropriate and its extent.

For illustration only, a 25% reduction applied to agreed damages of £10,000 leaves £7,500 before any separate costs or deductions. This is arithmetic, not a prediction of the percentage or value in a particular case. Obtain advice before accepting a proposed split of responsibility.

Build an evidence file around the disputed points

  • Your account: a dated description of the route, manoeuvres, lane positions, signals and sequence of events. Separate what you remember from estimates.
  • Independent evidence: witness contact details, photographs, dashcam material and available CCTV. Ask promptly about preserving footage before it is overwritten.
  • The scene and vehicles: road layout, markings, sight lines, vehicle positions and damage. Avoid unsafe attempts to recreate an accident.
  • Other accounts: the insurer’s denial, the other driver’s version and relevant correspondence. Identify exactly where the accounts differ.
  • Injury and losses: treatment records, symptoms, wage records and receipts. Responsibility for the collision and the effect on your health and finances are separate questions.

Keep original files and explain any missing evidence or uncertainty. Do not alter footage, coach witnesses or fill gaps with assumptions. Ask how to provide confidential records securely.

Do police records or expert reports settle the issue?

Police records may provide relevant evidence, but their contents and significance need assessment alongside the other material. A civil claim is not determined simply by whether police attended or brought a prosecution. Accident reconstruction, medical or other expert evidence may help where a specific issue requires it; not every claim needs every type of expert. Discuss necessity, proportionality and costs before commissioning a report.

What happens after an insurer denies responsibility?

The next step depends on the claims process and the evidence. It may involve asking for clarification, supplying further material, challenging the denial or considering court proceedings. For claims within the Official Injury Claim process, the RTA Small Claims Protocol sets out the procedure, including disputed liability. It does not apply to every road accident claim. Obtain advice about the route, deadlines and costs before issuing proceedings.

If the driver was uninsured or cannot be identified, read our separate uninsured driver and hit-and-run claims guide.

Request a liability assessment

Qazi & Co Solicitors in Hendon, London can assess the accident account, disputed findings and available evidence. Bring the accident date, insurer correspondence, photographs or footage, witness details and relevant injury information. Tell us about any approaching deadline; discussions with an insurer should not be assumed to protect it.

See our personal injury services and funding assessment or call 020 3161 5450 to request a personal injury assessment. A conditional fee agreement may be available for a suitable claim following assessment. We explain the agreed scope, potential costs and deductions in writing before instruction. No outcome or compensation amount can be guaranteed.

This article provides general information, not advice on an individual case. The appropriate procedure, time limit and funding depend on the circumstances.

Seraphinite AcceleratorOptimized by Seraphinite Accelerator
Turns on site high speed to be attractive for people and search engines.